A Curious Case of Bedrooms and Buttons
Friday the 13th... I find that an appropriate day to talk about Coraline.
Coraline movie still © 2009 Laika Entertainment.
The movie, directed and written for the screen by Henry Selick, is infectious, and certain set pieces are spectacular. Depending on how audiences react to the darker aspects, it's sure to become either a cult or mass favorite. But very early on I got that familiar feeling: I kinda wished I hadn't read the book.
Written by Neil Gaiman, Coraline the book was good (also quite acclaimed; it won a Hugo and other awards given to SF, horror, or fantasy). The "problem" is that the book called heavily upon our imagination to illustrate Coraline's worlds, aided — and this is important — by the cover and occasional black-&-white interior art of Dave McKean. Gaiman & McKean broke into the American comics market together over 20 years ago with Black Orchid for DC, and McKean produced covers for Gaiman's landmark series The Sandman. The pair also began collaborating on such children's books as The Day I Swapped My Dad for Two Goldfish long before Gaiman was adult-prose-fiction bestseller Neil Gaiman, author of American Gods. More to the point, the duo made the film MirrorMask, which I now really, really want to see, because while I didn't remember much about Coraline the book in detail I clearly remembered McKean's artwork, and while its mood was reflected in posters I've seen it wasn't the basis for the look of Coraline the movie — not a complaint, but still inevitable baggage.
Jacket art © 2002 Dave McKean. Poster © 2009 Laika Entertainment.
I also remembered that the book was dark, and the film, while not as dark, is indeed rated PG. We're talking about a girl with inattentive parents who's moved to a new house (a very familiar trope in children's fiction) and soon discovers that she can visit a magical world with much friendlier, cooler, and, well, more magical people and things than exist in the dreary world she leaves behind, but of course staying there will come at a terrible price. My 6-plus niece could probably handle it, although not without a grownup in the next seat for reassurance; my 4-plus niece could not — yet there were little ones being walked and even carried by their parents into the theater, only to be walked or carried out when the going got spooky. Did Mom or Dad not catch one ad, clip, or review that alluded to the movie's wicked witch wanting to sew buttons onto Coraline's eyes?
We saw the 3D version of the film. I hadn't used these newfangled glasses before, which are tinted but not colored red/green or red/blue like the old days, allowing for the movie itself to be in color. And we were lucky to sit next to an entire family with kids of appropriate age, all of whom loved the film, the mother most of all — she not only laughed freely, but pointed at the screen in delight. (We were unlucky enough to sit in front of a kid who sounded much too old for the occasional loud, thuddingly literal narration that he provided, but them's the breaks.) I recommend the 3D despite the fact that it's still a gimmick that carries the drawback of reminding you that you're immersed in artifice at the same time it impresses you. The glasses do make the screen image dimmer, but it's possible that the brightness of the screen was turned up to compensate for this as it was quite vibrant when I peeked out from under them; in any event, Coraline is not a story in which some gloom is inappropriate.
As a bonus, the movie was preceded by an extended trailer from an upcoming Ice Age movie that effectively worked as a stand-alone short. I haven't seen any of the Ice Ages, but I recognized Skrat, who here gets into a winning Pepé Le Pew adventure to the strains of personal fave Lou Rawls. Perhaps I could arrange an Ice Age/MirrorMask double feature.
I really enjoyed Henry Selick's The Nightmare before Christmas (produced by Tim Burton and officially titled Tim Burton's The Nightmare before Christmas, which has led The Chicago Tribune and other news outlets to erroneously tout reviews of Tim Burton's Coraline). And stop-motion animation has brought us Wallace & Gromit and such Rankin-Bass favorites as Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer. Early on, though, Coraline looked so fluid to me that I assumed CGI was involved — not that CGI is renowned for its fluidity; it's just that stop-motion is almost inevitably a little jerky and I figured computers were used to smooth out some transitions (for the record, the filmmakers have said that the only digital work done was erasure of wires and such, just as in live-action movies with stunt sequences). The movements of the characters also looked exaggerated, as if they were projecting to the back row, which combined with the overexpressiveness of some of the voices really began to deflate my enthusiasm for the film.
Either the movie changed as it went on or my perceptions did, however, because easily a third of the way in I was completely enraptured. There is joyous visual inventiveness that would not have been possible with the spare, black-&-white illustrations of the book. While the story echoes The Wizard of Oz and Alice's Adventures in Wonderland with its colorful neighbors and alternate-world travelogue, Coraline's ability to travel back and forth to the bizarre home of her Other Mother and the tragic fate that ultimately awaits her there hearken back to the darker fairy tales of the Brothers Grimm — Coraline isn't offered a secretly poisoned apple, she's asked to willingly give up her eyes, and that's not even the twist.
The soundtrack deserves special mention as a winner from start to finish. Composed by Bruno Coulais, it also features a new song from They Might Be Giants performed in the film by the Other Father; until I saw the credits, it had me musing that John Hodgman didn't sing half bad.
Dakota Fanning does a fine job as Coraline, but it's a shame that most animated films today cast movie or television stars instead of professional voice actors in leading roles (even smaller-scale films, often as a condition of financing). When mannerisms and facial characteristics are based on the stars in big-budget animated comedies, this works better, but here those who know Hodgman from The Daily Show or Mac-vs.-PC commercials have to adjust to his voice coming from the lanky frame of Coraline's dad, and Teri Hatcher's character only resembles her towards the end — and it's not a flattering comparison.
On the other hand, Ian McShane disappears into the role of mouse-circus ringleader Mr. Bobinsky, who looks like a Russian cousin to the Blue Meanies of Yellow Submarine, while the Absolutely Fabulous duo of Jennifer Saunders (whose show-stopping performance of a terrible song was nearly the only thing I liked in the first Shrek sequel) and Dawn French play spinster neighbors Miss Spink and Miss Forcible — portlier versions of the aunts on the much-missed Pushing Daisies, albeit with divining abilities and decidedly more burlesque in their old act. Most bewitching was Keith David as the voice of the Cat, who sounded for all the world like a seductive Esther Rolle. The less said about Wybie, a boy who befriends Coraline (not found in book but added so that she had someone besides herself to talk to onscreen), the better — though he admittedly provides some early pathos in the Other Mother's world.
Some of my favorite films have totally frustrating moments of plot, casting, or other creative decisions that keep them from being perfect, but usually they let me down near the end instead of the beginning as did Coraline, which grew in my estimation considerably. I recommend it to everyone open to fantasy or innovative filmmaking, nearly worth the price of admission for the schnauzer bats alone.
Coraline is available from Amazon on DVD, in a Blu-Ray/DVD combo and in a Blu-Ray gift set as well as via Amazon Instant Video. If you purchase those or any other items placed into your cart via the preceding links, Blam's Blog may get a small percentage of the sale.